Labels

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

ADC Thanks Ms. Helen Thomas for Legendary Service

http://www.adc.org/media/press-releases/2010/june-2010/adc-thanks-ms-helen-thomas-for-legendary-service/
ADC Thanks Ms. Helen Thomas for Legendary Service

Washington, DC | June 9, 2010 | www.adc.org | Helen Thomas, 89, Dean of the White House Press Corp, and lauded as a "Pioneer Journalist" and Trailblazer for female journalists," apologized for her May 27, 2010, response when she was asked "Any comments on Israel...?" and she responded "Tell them to get the [] out of Palestine." Upon further prodding, Ms. Thomas stated that "Remember these people are occupied and it's their land..." and those who are the occupiers should "...go home" to "Poland, Germany...And America and everywhere else."

In her apology, Ms. Thomas wrote: "I deeply regret my comments I made last week regarding the Israelis and the Palestinians. They do not reflect my heartfelt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance. May that day come soon."

The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC) thanks Ms. Thomas for her legendary service, and acknowledges Ms. Thomas' apology. ADC believes that Ms. Thomas should be judged on her "50-plus years of probing journalism, and not on a 30-second sound bite," as stated by Mr. Zool Zulkowitz, who represents American Jews defending Ms. Thomas. Mr. Zulkowitz further said that, "We are clear what Helen Thomas meant to say, which is that Israel should cease its occupation of Palestine..." And, as Mr. Paul Jay wrote: "Not all criticism of Israel is anti-Semitism...Helen Thomas' isn't."

As President Obama recognized in his historic address in Cairo on June 4, 2009, the Palestinian people - Muslims and Christians - have endured the pain of dislocation for more than 60 years. "Many wait in refugee camps in the West Bank, Gaza, and neighboring lands for a life of peace and security that they have never been able to lead. They endure the daily humiliations - large and small - that come with occupation. So let there be no doubt: The situation for the Palestinian people is intolerable ..."

It is our hope that other journalists would rise in Ms. Thomas' place and espouse her courage in asking the hard questions. As Ms. Katrina Vanden Heuvel wrote yesterday in the Washington Post: "...isn't there room for someone who made a mistake, apologized and wants to continue speaking truth to power and asking tough questions?" We certainly hope so. We also hope that we will continue to celebrate Ms. Thomas' lifetime of courageous, frontline journalism; and that she will not be intimidated by the recent hateful accusations or deterred from her insightful questioning and reporting.

###

Contact: Sara Najjar-Wilson, President

media@adc.org

202-244-2990

NOTE TO EDITORS: The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), which is non-profit, non-sectarian and non-partisan, is the largest Arab-American civil rights organization in the United States. It was founded in 1980 by former Senator James Abourezk to protect the civil rights of people of Arab descent in the United States and to promote the cultural heritage of the Arabs. ADC has 38 chapters nationwide, including chapters in every major city in the country, and members in all 50 states.

The ADC Research Institute (ADC-RI), which was founded in 1981, is a Section 501(c)(3) educational organization that sponsors a wide range of programs on behalf of Arab Americans and of importance to all Americans. ADC-RI programs include research studies, seminars, conferences and publications that document and analyze the discrimination faced by Arab Americans in the workplace, schools, media, and governmental agencies and institutions. ADC-RI also celebrates the rich cultural heritage of the Arabs.

From Growing Gardens for Palestine... Honor

Growing Gardens for Palestine

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Honor

There is a fascinating news story this week about a stolen letter returned: Thinking man's mystery: Stolen Descartes letter returned

It has a happy ending... a happy ending only possible because of the research skills, the empathy, the Internet, the hard work and the good intentions of the people involved.

Recently I remembered this poem that I wrote many years ago, and I am posting it here in my Growing Gardens for Palestine blog, to honor Helen Thomas as she retires- to honor her as best as I can.

Other than being a human being, and oh yeah a woman, I have very little in common with Helen Thomas, but I do have great admiration for her legendary service.

Yesterday my dear friend and fellow blogger UmKhalil told me in a note that the last lines of my old poem describe her well...

An Arab Mind

To understand
an Arab mind
one must see Jordan in the Spring.

Wander through a Spring meadow,
cherish the brief blossoming
from brilliant poppy
to tiny delicate sunlit star-
purple thistles, blue flax, pinkish roses, all
come bursting from rock
and earth
and everywhere
where a seed might stray
there is bloom
and each bloom
seems infused
with purpose.

Enshallah...

Understand
that the Arab mind
holds the perpetual memory
of Spring:

Shivering, stand in wet snow
listening to thunder,
as sleet melts
into rainfall
diffusing,
as the sun's glinting light

pulls forth a pretty posy here and there

and barrages of bloom rupture the earth.

Day after day of bloom bursting
and the deep indigo
of an oriental night
is fragrant.

By day the desert heat
comes back
to claim all color,
washing the hills with brown stubble
which the goats will graze to aught.

Presume, as you stand on barren stone
that soon enough, next spring-

Enshallah...

This rock ledge will once again
brim
with flowers

and a crumbling castle
will be a thousand urns
of growth.


Anne Selden Annab

Years ago in the late 1980s, when my husband first introduced me and our newly born son to his extended family- and the Arab world, I wrote many poems about my impressions. I did not, however, write poems about anything negative. Although, perhaps, I could have written quite a long epic poem exploring how utterly exhausted-frustrated- furious- hormonal- helpless and everything else I felt when standing in line to get off one of several seemingly endless flights we had to take to get to Jordan. The steward of an Air France flight warmly complimented us on how our wide awake baby was so well behaved during the long flight, and my husband cheerfully bragged that it was easy to keep him quiet. HELLO- it was not easy for me at all!

I now see that incident, and my husband's comment, in a very different light- but at the time it ... well let us just say that there is at least one very long epic poem I refuse to waste time or effort creating!

The older we get the more I understand that even in the most difficult situations we can choose to do the right thing, even when it is the hardest thing to do. We can "rise to the occasion" as my Grandmother used to say.

This week there are many people, including Obama and Abbas, as well as many organizations and officials who are sincerely doing all they can to try to help create a just and lasting peace in the Middle East. Give them a chance please- listen and try to use empathy and compassion to understand what they have to say.

I do not know what will be. But I do know that both Palestine and peace need all our best efforts- now more than ever.

NOTES
Peacemaking takes courage, leaders

Israel must clarify Palestine's status

The Arab Peace Initiative


poem & photo copyright ©2010 Anne Selden Annab

Join the facebook group "Helen Thomas should have been our graduation speaker"


Helen Thomas was almost the graduation speaker for the Walt Whitman High School Class of 2010.

The purpose of this group is to quietly but firmly protest the ability of a small minority to impose its will on the larger group through engaging or threatening to engage in disruptive discourse. This group affirms a belief in reasonable discussion and feel that in this scenario, a clear minority was able to override a larger majority by distorting the issues and discussion.

Regarding Dr. Goodwin's decision:
We understand and accept the rationale for changing graduation speakers given the divisiveness in the community. As Dr. Goodwin stated, graduation is a time for cohesiveness, not divisiveness. However, we firmly protest that small minority of voices which was intent on politicizing an traditionally wonderful ceremony and dividing the community based purely on their political views. Their advocacy unfairly forced the change of graduation speaker.

from wikipedia:
Helen Thomas (born August 4, 1920) is an American news service reporter, a Hearst Newspapers columnist, member of the White House Press Corps and author. She served for fifty-seven years as a correspondent and, later, White House bureau chief for United Press International (UPI). Thomas has covered every President of the United States since the later years of the Eisenhower administration, coming to the forefront with John F. Kennedy. She was the first female officer of the National Press Club, the first female member and president of the White House Correspondents Association, and, in 1975, the first female member of the Gridiron Club. She has written five books; her latest with co-author Craig Crawford is Listen Up, Mr. President: Everything You Always Wanted Your President to Know and Do.

Nothing we do will change our graduation speaker now, however it would be nice to know I am not alone in preferring that a legend like Helen Thomas had spoken at our graduation.

join the facebook group Helen Thomas should have been our graduation speaker

My letters to the LA Times, the Philadelphia Inquirer & the NYTimes regarding Helen Thomas' real triumph & Palestinian investments in nonviolence


RE: "Helen Thomas: A troubling end to a distinguished career"
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/editorials/la-ed-thomas-20100609,0,4996898.story

Dear Editor,

A troubling end to Helen Thomas' career? NOPE- you've got the wrong end of the stick. Helen Thomas' real triumph has been to top a ground breaking professional career in journalism by gracefully retiring on such a boldly honest- and frankly helpful note. Take what she said in full context, quoted correctly and make war or peace with it- your choice... but please do not ignore official US policy which advocates a two state solution (Israel get out of Palestine) to end the 60 year long Israel/Palestine conflict.

Do you really want American tax dollars (as well as charity funds) to continue to help subsidize and defend Israel's settlers in the illegally occupied territories- and do you really want to ignore the fact that many of Israeli's settlers all through out the illegally occupied territories are recent arrivals from Europe, Russia and America. Surely there are better investments for everyone's sake.

And last but not least: Do you really want to so rudely ignore Helen Thomas' beautiful letter perfect apology "I deeply regret my comments I made last week regarding the Israelis and the Palestinians. They do not reflect my heart-felt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance. May that day come soon." Helen Thomas .

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

********************************
RE: Editorial: Unconscionable
http://www.philly.com/inquirer/opinion/20100609_Editorial__Unconscionable.html#axzz0qMFzl2JL

Dear Editor,

Helen Thomas is not an idiot or a bigot. She has been unfairly attacked and maligned. The United States, along with the international community, officially backs a two state solution to end the sixty year long Israel/Palestine conflict. To create two separate, viable sovereign states, one being called Israel and the other Palestine, Israel obviously needs to stop building settlements in the illegally occupied territories and Israel needs to get its settlers and troops out of Palestine.

Furthermore, and this really is crucially important- the vast majority of Palestinians, the native non-Jewish population of the Holy Land, are impoverished refugees, refused their inalienable legal and natural right to return to original homes and lands.

Israel scorns Palestinian rights, impoverishes Palestinians, displaces Palestinians and adds insult to injury by generously subsidizing Jewish settlers in the illegally occupied territories, pushing even more Palestinians into forced exile and despair. A significant portion of Israel's generously subsidized and heavily protected settlers are recent arrivals from Europe, Russia and America. Where those settlers 'return home' to is a very relevant and timely question. They have been pawns in a cruel game but they need to take responsibility for their own actions- their own bad choices and their own contributions to continuing the conflict.

Yes, maybe Helen Thomas could have been more diplomatic and obtuse with how she said what she said. But if she had, would any one have paid attention?

Kudos to Thomas for ending her amazing, ground breaking career on such an honest and necessary note- including but not limited to her apology and her hope for peace in the Middle East. ("I deeply regret my comments I made last week regarding the Israelis and the Palestinians. They do not reflect my heart-felt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance. May that day come soon." Helen Thomas )

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab


*************************************

RE: Palestinian Takes a Road Less Traveled
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/09/world/middleeast/09iht-letter.html?ref=middleeast

Dear Editor,

I very much hope that Palestinians continue on this path of nonviolence and careful, compassionate objections to Israel's not so careful or compassionate treatment of the native non-Jewish population of the Holy Land. Ending the conflict needs to be a priority for everyone's sake- and, as Hussein Ibish explains in his persuasive book
What's Wrong with the One-State Agenda? a viable, secular two state solution is the only way forward.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab


NOTES
Peacemaking takes courage, leaders

Israel must clarify Palestine's status

The Arab Peace Initiative


My letter to the New York Review of Books RE 'The Failure of the American Jewish Establishment': An Exchange June 24, 2010

RE:Letters
'The Failure of the American Jewish Establishment': An Exchange June 24, 2010
In response to:
The Failure of the American Jewish Establishment from the June 10, 2010 issue

Dear Editor,

Thank you for not letting Abraham H. Foxman have the last word with his letter responding to The Failure of the American Jewish Establishment . This past week the Foxman's ADL along with Rabbi David Nesenoff , White House press secretary Robert Gibbs, former White House Counsel Lanny Davis, and Ari Fleischer former White House press secretary (to name a few major players) very much helped create and exasperate a defamatory and cruel hate campaign against Helen Thomas, forcing her to resign.

Israel's settlement projects and apartheid polices in the illegally occupied Palestinian territories combined with Avigdor Lieberman’s "crusade to humiliate, disenfranchise, and perhaps even eventually expel Arab Israelis" puts Palestinians, the native non-Jewish population of the Holy Land, in a totally impossible situation. Already the vast majority of Palestinians have been pushed into forced exile and cruelly denied their inalienable legal and natural right to return to original homes and lands... How many more Palestinian men, women and children must be persecuted and displaced (and how many more naive folks world wide will be conned into either inadvertently or purposefully empowering Islamists) while Israel and its supporters bicker and battle on and on about perceived "identity" crises?


Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

NOTES
Peacemaking takes courage, leaders

Israel must clarify Palestine's status

The Arab Peace Initiative

My letter to the Washington Post RE Helen Thomas agrees to bow out as commencement speaker at Walt Whitman High




Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Mahmoud Abbas: Peacemaking takes courage, leaders

http://thehill.com/opinion/op-ed/101843-a-moment-of-truth-peacemaking-requires-courage-and-leadership

OPINION: Peacemaking takes courage, leaders

By Mahmoud Abbas - 06/08/10 06:00 AM ET

Negotiations between Palestinians and Israelis have resumed after a year and a half of a stalemate that began after Israel launched its devastating military assault against the Gaza Strip in December 2009. The resumption of negotiations came as a result of concerted and persistent efforts by the U.S. administration and by President Barack Obama in particular, together with extensive Palestinian, Arab and international support.

This round of negotiations provides an 11th-hour opportunity to achieve a permanent and lasting peace based on the two-state solution. For the opportunity not to be lost, courage and bold leadership are required.

Despite the harsh realities imposed upon us, the Palestinian side intends to negotiate in good faith in order to end the state of conflict that has plagued our region for so long. Achieving peace and coexistence between Palestinians and Israelis has been my lifelong commitment. I came to believe from an early stage that the Palestinian-Israeli conflict cannot be resolved without dialogue. This vision has guided my political thinking and work for the last 35 years.

I was the first among Palestinian leaders to establish and encourage dialogue between Palestinians and Israelis as early as the 1970s. These early activities paved the way for the signing of the Oslo Accord in 1993. Ever since, I have worked hard, together with my colleagues in the Palestinian leadership, to end the conflict and achieve peace. Since taking office, I have never walked away from serious negotiations, and

I do not intend to. However, we cannot be asked to negotiate forever as reality on the ground deteriorates by the hour.

The Oslo Accord and subsequent peace plans and initiatives such as the U.S.-sponsored Road Map required Israel to stop all Israeli settlement activities in the occupied Palestinian territory. Yet, consecutive Israeli governments have continued to expand settlements. These settlements being deemed illegal by the international community and an obstacle to peace, has not stopped the Israeli leadership; the number of settlers has tripled in size since the signing of the Oslo Accord.

Meaningful negotiations and Israeli settlement activity do not go hand in hand because the continued building of settlements will not leave enough land for us to establish our own contiguous and viable state. It is for this very reason that I have insisted on the need to stop all settlement activities before the resumption of direct negotiations. Those who insist on continuing settlement activities cannot be serious about the two-state solution or peacemaking as a whole.

Unilateral measures jeopardize the prospects of achieving a negotiated peace agreement. I have always rejected unilateral steps by either side and continue to do so, be it the Israeli unilateral redeployment from Gaza, the building of Israeli settlements, the separation wall or a one-sided declaration of a Palestinian state.

With the full support of the U.S. and the international community, we are currently building the institutions of our future state. We are making great progress, and we are determined to do more.

We recognize that Israelis have concerns about their security. The need for security is paramount to both peoples. Given that the security of Israel and Palestine has become inseparable, we Palestinians have a vested interest in seeing Israelis living in peace and security in their state next to the Palestinian state. I refuse to allow the just struggle of my people for freedom and independence to be exploited by extremists, regardless of who they are. For extremism to be defeated, we must all redouble our efforts to bring about a just and lasting peace between Israelis and Palestinians.

It is time to break with the past and look forward to the future. In the Arab Peace Initiative, 57 Arab and Muslim countries offered Israel peace and normalized relations in return for Israel’s withdrawal from the Palestinian and Arab territories it conquered by force in the 1967 War and has occupied since. Israeli leaders have so far failed to grasp this historic opportunity and instead are actively working toward making the two-state solution impossible.

I have great faith in the fairness of the American people, who have struggled so admirably to achieve and maintain their freedom and independence. The Palestinian people want the same things that Americans want: to live in freedom and security and to have the opportunity for our families and loved ones to prosper.

Palestinians and Israelis are destined to live together. Resolving this conflict, once and for all, is not only in the interest of the peoples of the region, but is also of utmost importance to U.S. national interests. If there ever was a global issue that begged for courage and leadership, it is this issue and now.

Mahmoud Abbas is the President of the Palestinian National Authority and Chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Israel must clarify Palestine's status

Hussein Ibish: "Palestinians cannot be expected to acquiesce to, much less subsidise, their own oppression and they have every right to peacefully and lawfully challenge the occupation and demand clarity.

The same logic ultimately applies to the PA state and institution building programme. By developing the framework of Palestinian statehood, the programme forces Israel into the clarity of a simple choice: either gradually and however grudgingly cede more and more attributes of sovereignty in greater and greater parts of the occupied territories to the PA in order to allow the programme to develop, or kill it. The state building programme cannot survive stasis. It requires continuous, even if gradual, expansion. It asks Israel a simple question: are the occupied territories ultimately your country or ours?"

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/07/israel-must-clarify-palestine-status

Israel must clarify Palestine's status

The Palestinian boycott of settlement goods demands Israel addresses the territory's ambiguous legal and political status

umkahlil: Plain Speaking from Helen Thomas, Dean of White House Press Corps

umkahlil: Plain Speaking from Helen Thomas, Dean of White House Press Corps

My letter to the Washington Post RE Helen Thomas agrees to bow out as commencement speaker at Walt Whitman High

Helen Thomas interviewing JFK

RE: Helen Thomas agrees to bow out as commencement speaker at Walt Whitman High
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/20/AR2007022000709.html

Dear Editor,

I admire Helen Thomas, she has had an impressive career and really has been a great reporter, an astute questioner as well as an excellent role model for all our children.

I do not admire Helen Thomas' detractors who have been quick to demonize her and destroy her career and her reputation by distorting what she meant. I get what she said- I understand it, not as bigotry but as deep frustration over sovereign Israel's generously subsidized settlers and apartheid polices in the illegally occupied territories.

Israel's institutionalized bigotry pushes Palestinians into an impossible situation by persecuting, impoverishing and displacing the native non-Jewish Palestinians, fragmenting Palestinian families and refusing to respect the Palestinian refugees inalienable legal and natural right to return to original homes and lands, while at the same time refusing to allow a viable real Palestinian state to emerge.

Dr. Hussein Ibish of the American task Force on Palestine points out in a recent article in The Guardian: Israel must clarify Palestine's status "While Israeli settlers live under Israeli civil law and with all the rights and responsibilities of citizenship, Palestinians live under Israeli civil and military administration with a very different set of laws and without the rights or responsibilities of citizenship. This structure based on dual registers of reality in the same space extends throughout the entire system of the occupation." http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/07/israel-must-clarify-palestine-status

Clarity is crucial if we want to help build a just and lasting peace in the Middle East- and for clarity we need more reporters like Helen Thomas.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab



Sunday, June 6, 2010

My letter to NPR- All Things Considered RE Pro-Palestinian groups being heard- interview with Hussein Ibish

Israeli Raid Presents Opportunity For Palestinians
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=127501651

Dear NPR- All Things Considered,

I very much liked your interview with Dr Ibish regarding opportunities for Palestine. He really does have the perfect voice for NPR. I like both what he says- and how he says it. Please have him on more often!

I'd also be interested in hearing more about emerging non-violent strategies for Palestine, including state and institution building initiatives.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab


Do you see an opportunity... Dr. IBISH: Yes. NPR Interview with ATFP Senior Fellow

Do you see an opportunity...

Dr. IBISH: Yes.

RAZ: ...for pro-Palestinian advocacy groups in Washington right now?

Dr. IBISH: Definitely, there is one if they take advantage of it. And I think to do that, you have to appeal to the American national interest to get people's attention.

I think there are three paradigm shifts. The first is the one most obviously implicit in your question that there's a new context in which Israeli conduct is being viewed internationally, including in the United States and maybe, in a way, especially in the United States.

There's a second very important paradigm shift on the Palestinian side, especially in the West Bank, where you've seen a real commitment to emerging non-violent strategies, state and institution building in a very high level, settlement boycotts that's non-violent and tries to make a distinction between the settlements and Israel itself. This is a major paradigm shift in the Palestinian approach.

And there's a third paradigm shift and I think it's very important in the context of the ability of pro-Palestine groups in Washington to have a seat at the table, which is I think we are now increasingly, all of us - Jewish Americans, Arab Americans and others, understanding this is not a zero sum conflict. It's not as if everything good for Israel is bad for the Palestinians and vice versa.

But I think it's becoming increasingly clear on both sides we need a partnership and we need it now, because our friends and relatives in the Middle East and our own country here need the same thing, which is a peace agreement, a two-state peace agreement... read more

Israeli Raid Presents Opportunity For Palestinians

June 5, 2010

Israel's decision this week to send armed commandos onto a ship carrying activists sparked international condemnation. It also provided a political platform for Palestinian activists at home -- and abroad -- to further their case for a homeland. Host Guy Raz talks with Hussein Ibish, a senior fellow at the American Task Force, about whether pro-Palestinian groups are finding it easier to be heard.

Peaceful resistance letter by Wasseem AlKury of Amman


Before the war on Gaza one-and-a-half years ago, talking to friends, I used to say that nonviolent resistance is the strongest way to fight off the Israeli occupation of Palestinians’ lives and lands, and gain independence and freedom.

Every time I would give my opinion, I would hear strong criticism from most listeners.

Today, nonviolent resistance proves successful. It achieved in few years what violent resistance did not achieve in many.

BDS (boycott, divest and sanctions) campaigns against Israel succeeded in making many supermarkets in the US and Europe boycott products originating from Israeli settlements. Did violent resistance ever achieve that?

BDS campaigns succeeded in making large financial funds and banks in Europe divest from companies involved in building the apartheid wall, many artists cancel their shows in Israel and many universities in Europe refuse to cooperate with Israeli universities in Israeli settlements.

Today, a significant number of international supporters demonstrate every Friday against building the apartheid wall and settlements on Palestinian territories. Most importantly, thousands of Israelis demonstrate weekly against occupation and ethnic cleansing in East Jerusalem.

When did bombs in malls and public transport buses succeed in achieving that?

The Palestinian president and the prime minister signed a new law that bans products from Israeli settlements from entering West Bank markets and this put settlers’ economy in danger. Did violent resistance succeed in achieving this goal?

Last week, after the Freedom Flotilla incident, countries strongly criticised Israel’s siege on Gaza and are strongly urging Israel to lift it, with no preconditions. When did the useless rockets achieve that?

The list of nonviolent resistance success stories can go on.

Three factors will make Palestinians achieve their independence: continuing strong nonviolent resistance; building their economy as the government in the West Bank is already doing; uniting as soon as possible, especially since Hamas agreed last week to a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders.

This will lead to an independent Palestinian state that the whole world will recognise, whether Israel likes it or not.

Wasseem AlKury,
Amman

6 June 2010